Idaho Real Estate Appraiser Board
Bureau of Occupational Licenses
1109 Main Street, Suite 220
Boise, Idaho 83702-5642
(208) 334-3233

Minutes of October 17, 2005   

ROLL CALL:   Henri Le Moyne -Chair
                        Ruby Stroschein, Board Member
                        Paul J Morgan, Board Member
                        Stanley Moe, Board Member
                        Rick Bachmeier, Board Member                             

PRESENT:     Rayola Jacobsen, Bureau Chief
                       Budd Hetrick, Deputy Bureau Chief
                       Stephanie Guyon, Deputy Attorney General
                       Roger Hales, Administrative Attorney
                       Sandee Hitesman, Administrative Assistant II
                       Maria Brown, Technical Records Specialist I

OTHERS PRESENT:  Jeffery Allen James, Applicant
                                    Jared B. Perry, Applicant
                                    Susan Robbins, ASFMRA

The meeting was called to order at 9:05 a.m. by Chair, Henri Le Moyne.   

The board requested to talk to Roger Hales about the AQB required date.

The board reviewed the minutes from the August12, 2005 board meeting. 

Motion was made by Mr. Morgan to accept the board meeting minutes from the August 12, 2005 board meeting as written.  Seconded by Mr. Bachmeier, carried. 

Ms. Jacobsen, gave the financial report.  As of September 30, 2005, the board had $126,149.93 in appropriation with a cash balance of $127,724.19.   

Mr. Hetrick, gave the investigative report.  For 2006 there have been 3 complaints received.  All of which are under investigation.  For fiscal year 2005 there were 35 complaints.  33 of these are currently under investigation, and one has been referred for formal action.  There were 38 complaints for fiscal year 2004.  Seven of these complaints have been closed, 3 have been referred for formal action, 27 are under investigation or pro-review and 1 awaits board determination.  There were 32 complaints for fiscal year 2003.  20 of these have been closed, 5 are under investigation or pro-review and 7 have been referred for formal action.  There were 32 complaints for fiscal year 2002.  21 of these have been closed, 2 are under investigation or pro-review, 8 have been referred for formal action, and 1 awaits Board determination. 

Mr. Moe arrived at 9:15 a.m.

Mr. Hetrick, Deputy Bureau Chief, presented an investigative report for case #REA- S2-2005-15. 

Motion was made by Ms. Stroschein to refer to the Real Estate Commission and follow up by Mr. Le Moyne for case # REA S2-2005-15.  Seconded by Mr. Bachmeier, carried. 

Mr. Hetrick presented an investigative report for case #REA- L3-2-2004-25. 

Motion was made by Mr. Moe to accept IBOL recommendation to close the investigation. Seconded by Ms. Stroschein, carried.

Mr. Hetrick presented an investigative report for case #REA- L3A-1-2003-31. 

Motion was made to accept the IBOL’s recommendation by Mr. Moe. Seconded by Mr. Bachmeier, carried.

Mr. Hetrick presented an investigative report for case #REA- P3-1-2002-53. 

Stephanie Guyon, Deputy Attorney General, informed the Board that she will be temporarily taking over all of the Boards.

Stephanie Guyon, presented a stipulation and consent order for case # REA-2005-6.

Board discussed the complaint about the mobile home appraisal. The stipulation recommended a fine, additional continuing education classes, probation for 6 months and required reinstatement of licensure. Respondent is not admitting fault. Continuing Education shall be included in maintaining his license. 

Mr. Morgan made a motion to accept the stipulation, with a letter listing classes that would be approved by the Board.  Ms. Stroschein seconded, carried.

Mr. Hales, Administrative Attorney, arrived at 9:25 a.m.

Mr. Hales addressed the board regarding the statues of water rights. Mr. Hales is continuing to research the law as to who has jurisdiction of the water rights.

The board asked Mr. Hales if it is misleading for a Certified Residential Appraiser to advertise as a Certified Appraiser. Mr. Hales will follow up on Idaho Code 54-4103 and  54-4104. Mr. Hales suggested to the Board that it may require a Law change being taken to the Legislature. The Board will address this issue at a future Board meeting.

Susan Robbins with ASFMRA addressed the board regarding the Winter Seminar for ASFMRA.  

Ms.Stroschein made a motion to accept the 12 hour continuing education. Seconded by Mr. Bachmeier, carried.

Ms. Stroschein informed the board that this may be her last meeting as a board member. She is stepping down. Mr. Morgan also informed the board that he is stepping down as a board member.

Mr. Moe addressed the board regarding the Fraud Seminar that he attended. Mr. Moe recommended that the board approve 7 hours of continuing education for this seminar. The Board suggested that Mr. Moe give a continuing education application to the provider of the seminar. The Board also recommended that the IBOL send post cards to all Licensed Real Estate Appraisers inviting them to the Fraud Seminar. Mr. Le Moyne will contact the Real Estate Commission to invite Realtors to the seminar.

The Board discussed case # REA- BKE-8-5-2005. Applicant is seeking reciprocity with Washington. Verification sent from Washington states that licensure was through passing the ASI in California. Board recommended that the applicant ask Washington to write a letter to the Idaho Real Estate Appraiser Board stating that Washington was an original state of licensure.

The board adjourned for a break at 10:45 a.m. 

Meeting was called back to order at 10:55 a.m. by chair, Mr. Le Moyne. 

Mr. Hales discussed the Law with the Board in regards to information for a licensee with a felony conviction. Mr. Hales suggested that the matter go to the Attorney General. Motion was made by Mr. Morgan for the Bureau to investigate and give the information to the Attorney General for their review and further action. Mr. Moe seconded, carried.

The board went into executive session to consider records exempt from public discloser as stated in 67-2345 (1) (d)

Ms. Stroschein made a motion to come out of executive session. Mr. Bachmeier seconded, carried.

The board reviewed applications for examination and licensure. The following applicants were approved for examination: 

Jared B. Perry for LRA exam

Micah Cranney for LRA exam

Yvonne Titus for CRA exam

Darian Robbins for LRA exam

Myken Goin for LRA exam

Sean Brown for CGA exam

The following applicants were approved for licensure:

John Emmerling for Licensure as a CGA

Louis B. Howard for Licensure as a CRA

The board adjourned for lunch at 12:20 p.m. 

Meeting was called back to order at 1:30 p.m. by chair, Mr. Le Moyne. 

Motion was made by Mr. Morgan to approve the following courses.  Seconded by Mr. Moe, carried.  

LINCOLN GRADUATE

637 Farm & Land Appraisal for 15 hours of CE        

649 Commercial Investment Appraisal for 15 hours of CE                        

685 Financial Analysis of Income Property for 15 hours of CE

686 Direct Capitalization of Income Property for 15 hours of CE

687 Yield Capitalization of Income Property for 15 hours of CE              

620 Appraiser Liability- Knowledge to Minimize Risk for 15 hours of CE          

659 Residential Cost Approach- Marshall & Swift for 15 hours of CE                                                                                                                                  

113 Scope of Work for 7.5 hours or CE                       

114 Understanding Fannie Mae’s Guidelines for 7.5 hours or CE

115 HUD Valuation Conditions Report for 7 hours or CE                          

121 The Truth About Mold for 7 hours or CE

THE AMERICAN SOCIETY OF FARM MANAGERS AND RURAL APPRAISERS, INC

A- 101 Basic Appraisal Principles for 30 hours of PL                                    

A-101 Basic Appraisal Principles for 28 hours of CE

Conservation Easement Valuation and Case Studies for 24 hours of CE

2005 Meeting for 14 hours of CE                           

A-12 II National USPAP Course for 15 hours of PL and 14 hours of CE

A-12 III 7 Hour National USPAP Course for 7 hours of CE                         

A-25 Eminent Domain for 21 hours of PL and 20 hours of CE                                             

A-27 Income Capitalization Unleveraged for 31 hours of PL and 28 hours of CE                     

A-29 Highest and Best Use for 16 hours of PL and 15 hours of CE                       

A-40 Advanced Rural Case Studies for 52 hours of PL and 48 hours of CE                 

Livestock Ranch Appraisal Part I Analysis for 8 hours of CE

Livestock Ranch Appraisal Part II Valuation for 8 hours of CE    

Timber and Timberland Valuation for 8 hours of CE

Appraising Agricultural Land in Transition for 8 hours of CE

Appraising Agricultural Land in Transition for 12 hours of CE

Yellow Book- Uniform Appraisal Standards for Federal Land Acquisition for 8 hours of CE

EXECUTRAIN OF IDAHO

Real Estate Appraisal Pre- License for 75 hours of  PL                  

NATIONAL BUSINESS INSTITUTE

Preserving Land Use Development Rights Through Subdivision for 7 hours of CE             

MCKISSOCK

Appraising the Oddball: Non- Conforming & Difficult Properties for 8 hours of CE   

THE COLUMBIA INSTITUTE

013 Recerts, Updates & You for 4 hours of CE                                 

101 USPAP Update for 8 hours of CE

103 Using the New Forms for 8 hours of CE

109 Review Appraisal Update for 8 hours of CE

APPRAISAL INSTITUTE

Uniform Appraisal Standards for Federal Land Acquisitions for 16 of CE        

Analyzing Commercial Lease Clauses for 7 hours of CE                          

INLAND NORTHWEST CHAPTER OF THE APPRAISAL INSTITUTE

Real Estate Agent, Appraiser, and Mortgage Fraud for 6 hours of CE

NORTHWEST FARM CREDIT SERVICES

Scope of Practice Rules- USPAP 2006 for 4 hours of CE

NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF INDEPENDENT FEE APPRAISERS

5.0A National USPAP Update for 7 hours of CE

9.8   2005 Fannie Mae Forms for 8 hours of CE

DYNASTY SCHOOL

Real Estate Appraisal for 21 hours of CE

The board reviewed continuing education audits.  All audits submitted were approved. 

Mr. Le Moyne addressed the board concerning the AQB date of January 1, 2008. At the last board meeting the board discussed proposing taking to legislation a Law change to meet the AQB requirements by January 1, 2007 in Idaho. The board phoned Mr. Hales to discuss why a change should take place in Idaho in 2007. Mr. Hales said that the reason the board had addressed it at their last board meeting was to make sure that Idaho was in compliance with Federal requirements.

The board set the next meeting date for December 12, 2005.

Meeting adjourned at 2:50 p.m.

Last Modified - April 11, 2006