Idaho Real Estate Appraiser Board
Minutes of August 17, 2004
The Idaho Real Estate Appraiser Board meeting was called to order at 8:30 a.m., Tuesday, August 17, 2004 at the Bureau of Occupational Licenses, Owyhee Plaza, 1109 Main Street, Suite 220, Boise, Idaho.
Roll Call: Doyle Pugmire, Chair
Paul Morgan, Board Member
Henri LeMoyne, Board Member
Stan Moe, Board Member
Ruby Stroschein, Absent
Bureau Staff: Rayola Jacobsen, Bureau Chief
Budd Hetrick, Deputy Bureau Chief
Roger Hales, Administrative Attorney
Patti Fanckboner, Secretary Idaho Real Estate Appraiser Board
Other: Victoria A. Ledbetter, Appraisal Subcommittee
Denise Hoage, Appraisal Subcommittee
Moved by Paul Morgan to approve the minutes of the June 21, 2004 Board meeting. Seconded by Henri Lemoyne,carried.
Rayola Jacobsen presented the Board with the Legislative Report. Rule changes discussed due to the National Level and defers to the end of the Board Meeting.
Budd Hetrick presented the Board with the Financial Report which was reviewed in detail.
Budd Hetrick presented the Board with the Investigative Report. Fiscal Year 2005, to date one complaint has been received and is under investigation. Fiscal Year 2004, thirty-eight (38) complaints were received. Three (3) have been closed; three (3) were referred for formal action; thirty-one (31) remain under investigation or pro-review; and one (1) awaits Board determination. Fiscal Year 2003, thirty-two (32) complaints were received. Thirteen (13) have been closed; twelve (12) are currently under investigation; one (1) awaits pro-review; four (4) were referred for formal action; and three (3) await Board determination. Fiscal Year 2002, Thirty (30) complaints were received. Of those three (3) are under investigation, one (1) awaits pro-review, and one (1) is pending legal review. Fiscal Year 2001, twenty-four (24) complaints were received. Of those, one (1) is undergoing pro-review.
REA-P3C-01-03-11 Motion by Henri LeMoyne to accept Bureau recommendations. Seconded by Stanley Moe, carried.
REA-P3A-2B-2003-29 Motion by Stanley Moe to accept Bureau recommendations. Seconded by Paul Morgan, carried .
REA-P3A-2B-2003-32 Motion by Stanley Moe to accept Bureau recommendation. Seconded by Paul Morgan, carried.
REA-P5B-02-2004-11 Motion by Paul Morgan for closure with an advisory letter. Seconded by Henri LeMoyne, carried.
REA-2004-3 Formal Action was deferred to conference call to be arranged by the investigative secretary.
Roger Hales presented the Board with a report and discussion regarding back- ground checks on prospective licensees in the future. The Board was advised that to implement back-ground checks it would require a law and rule change. Motion by Stanley Moe for Roger Hales to investigate this for a future licensing requirement. Seconded by Paul Morgan, carried.
Roger Hales then reviewed a petition with discussion to the Board to clarify and reconsider a consent order issued to Dominic Barone and Jim Donerkiel regarding the supervision of trainees and the time restraint. The Board does not have the authority to waive rules, the rules and the law apply to everyone. Motion by Henri LeMoyne for Roger Hales to respond to the petition. Seconded by Paul Morgan, carried.
Roger Hales presented the Board with Juan Vuittonet and Becky Kawano’s request to remove them from disciplinary action on the website with discussion. Motion by Stanley Moe not to remove them from the list and for Roger Hales to respond. Seconded by Henri LeMoyne, carried.
Roger Hales presented the Board with a discussion regarding issuing temporary permits and the Bureau’s role. All appraisers outside of Idaho who wish to perform an appraisal in Idaho, must obtain a temporary practice permit. Mr. Hales recommended that the Board set objective standards required to issue temporary permits. Motion by Henri LeMoyne to issue a temporary license to those who meet the requirements and to accept the following objective standards:
1) Federal 5 day requirement for processing
2) Possess current license in good standing
3) Passage of State Jurisprudence examination
4) Not to exceed 6 months, with a one-time extension if required
Seconded by Paul Morgan, carried.
The Board Secretary is authorized to retrieve license verification information from the Appraisal Subcommittee website to expedite the Federal requirements.
Motion by Henri LeMoyne to table discussion regarding registered trainees to receive continuing education for attending a Board meeting. Seconded by Stan Moe, carried.
Motion by Henri LeMoyne that Stan Moe attend the fall AARO Conference. Seconded by Paul Morgan, carried.
Motion by Stan Moe to send email to answer electronic survey of Studies of Appraisal in the Northwest. Seconded by Henri LeMoyne, carried.
Continuing Education
Continuing education requests reviewed. Motion by Paul Morgan to accept the National Business Institute (NBI) course “Land Use Planning and Eminent Domain in Idaho”, 7 hours continuing education. Seconded by Stan Moe, carried.
Motion by Henri LeMoyne not to accept continuing education request by Terry Rudd. After discussion it was determined that the Board has never given credit for publications. The secretary is to respond. Seconded by Paul Morgan, carried.
Applications Reviewed
The Board reviewed and approved four (4) applications for exam, and deferred ten (10) applications.
The Board has authorized the issuance of the following certifications/licenses to these individuals having met the educational and experience requirements and passing an examination approved by the Board.
Licensed Residential Certified General
Michael DeWitt Cindy Rastutis
Benjamin Mendez
Susan Miller
Wall certificates signed. The Board went into executive session to discuss matters not subject to public disclosure, the time being 11:20 a.m.
Denise Hoage and Victoria Ledbetter of the Appraisal Subcommittee attended this meeting and presented the Board with the findings of the performed audit. The audit was conducted on enforcement actions, application process, continuing education, and temporary practice permits. Some of the items discussed may require rule changes in the near future.
Meeting adjourned at 3 p.m.
Return to Idaho Real Estate Appraiser Board Home Page
Return to Bureau of Occupational Licenses Home Page
Last Modified - April 11, 2006