Idaho Real Estate Appraiser Board
Bureau of Occupational Licenses
1109 Main Street, Suite 220
Boise, Idaho 83702-5642
(208) 334-3233

Minutes of August 18, 2003

The Idaho Real Estate Appraiser Board meeting was called to order at 8:45 a.m., Monday, August 18, 2003 at the Bureau of Occupational Licenses, Owyhee Plaza, 1109 Main Street, Suite 220, Boise, Idaho. 

Roll Call:         Ruby Stroschein, Chair

                        Paul Morgan, Board Member

                        Stanley Moe, Board Member

                        Henri LeMoyne, Board Member 

Bureau Staff:   Rayola Jacobsen, Bureau Chief

                        Budd Hetrick, Deputy Bureau Chief

                        Roger Hales, Administrative Attorney

                        Marcie McGinty, Administrative Assistant

Doyle Pugmire, Board member, absent, excused. 

Minutes 

Moved by Paul Morgan, seconded by Stanley Moe and carried that the minutes of the June 24^th & 25^th 2003 board meeting be approved. 

Rayola Jacobsen 

Ms. Jacobsen presented the Board with proposed Law and Rule changes. 

Moved by Stanley Moe, seconded by Paul Morgan and carried that the Board accept the proposed Law change for Title 54-4105 and the proposed Rule changes for IDAPA 24, Title 18, Chapter 01. 

Budd Hetrick 

Mr. Hetrick presented the Financial Report and it was reviewed. 

Mr. Hetrick presented the 2004 Fiscal year renewal Bureau / Board contract with the Board. 

Moved by Stanley Moe, seconded by Henri LeMoyne and carried that the Board accept the contract as written. 

Complaint Report 

The Investigative Report was presented and discussed. 

Fiscal Year 2004.  To date five (5) complaints have been received and are under investigation.  Fiscal Year 2003.  Thirty-one (31) complaints have been received and are currently under investigation or legal review.  Fiscal Year 2002.  Twenty-one (21) complaints have been received.  Of those eighteen (18) remain open and under investigation or legal review.  Twenty-one (21) complaints have been received thus far for the year 2001.  of those, four (4) are under investigation the remaining ones are under legal review.  Thirty (30) complaints received were received for the year 2000.  Of those five (5) remain under investigation.  Eleven (11) are under legal review.  Forty-seven (47) complaints were received in 1999.  Twenty-two (22) are under legal review pending an administrative hearing.   Thirty-seven (37) complaints were reviewed in 1998.  Eight (8) are under legal review pending an administrative hearing.  Thirty-two (32) complaints were received in 1997.  Three (3) are being scheduled for an administrative hearing. 

Moved by Henri LeMoyne, seconded by Paul Morgan and carried that the Board go into executive session to discuss possible litigation.  The time being 9:35 a.m. 

Moved by Stanley Moe, seconded by Henri LeMoyne and carried that the Board come out of executive session at 10:30 a.m. 

REA-2004-1:  Moved by Henri LeMoyne, seconded by Stanley Moe and carried that the Board accept the Stipulation and Consent Order for David L. Votaw, CRA-163. 

REA-2003-11:  Moved by Paul Morgan, seconded by Henri LeMoyne and carried that the Board accept the Stipulated Reprimand And Final Order for Daniel C. Gregory, LRA-339. 

Moved by Henri LeMoyne, seconded by Stanley Moe and carried that Paul Morgan sign as interim chair to sign the two Stipulation and Consent Orders presented. 

The Final Order in the matter of George Haney, License No. LRA-86, REA-2003-8 was presented to and signed by Board Chair. 

2003 Continuing Education Renewal Audit 

After full review and discussion it was moved by Paul Morgan, seconded by Henri LeMoyne and carried that the Board accept the audit reports submitted by Idaho Real Estate Appraiser licensee’s for their 2003 continuing education renewal. 

Applications Reviewed 

The Board approved seven (7) application for exam and deferred four (4) applications. 

The Board has authorized the issuance of the following certificates / licenses to these individuals having met the educational and experience requirements and passing an examination required by the Board. 

Licensed Residential 

Michael M. Mick                Pete S. Simpson                       Allyson M. Knapp

Jack A. Saunders                      Rochelle L. Cvitanich               John R. Holt

Eldon H. Smith

The Board reviewed two (2) applications for registered trainee.  The Board has authorized the issuance of registered trainee status to these individuals having provided Seventy five (75) hours of education and providing documentation of a supervising appraiser who is in good standings with the Idaho board.  

Diane J. Taylor             Adam W. Burris

Approved Pre-Licensure & Continuing Education 

Allied Business Schools, Inc.  

Real Estate Appraisal:  Ninety (90) hours continuing education only. 

Allied National USPAP:  Fifteen (15) hours continuing education only.

Appraisal Webschool dba CompuTaught, Inc.  

7 Hour National USPAP Update:  Seven (7) hours continuing education, On-Line.

World Savings 

Foundations Of Real Estate Appraisal:  Thirty (30) hours pre-licensure and continuing education. 

Principals of Capitalization:  Thirty (30) hours pre-licensure and continuing education. 

Real Estate Appraisal Applications:  Thirty (30) hours pre-licensure and continuing education. 

Appraising The Single Family Residence:  Thirty (30) hours pre-licensure and continuing education. 

National USPAP:  Fifteen (15) hours pre-licensure and continuing education. 

Real Estate Appraisal Methods:  Thirty-three (33) hours pre-licensure and continuing education. 

National USPAP Update:  Seven (7) hours continuing education. 

Last Modified - April 11, 2006