Idaho Real Estate Appraiser Board
The Idaho Real Estate Appraiser Board meeting was
called to order at 8:35a.m., Monday, April 15, 2002 at the Bureau of
Occupational Licenses, Owyhee Plaza, 1109 Main Street, Suite 220, Boise, Idaho.
Roll Call:
Stanley Moe, Chairman; Paul Morgan,
Vice Chairman; Gordean Briggs; Doyle Pugmire;
Ruby Stroschein, absent, excused.
Bureau Staff:
Rayola Jacobsen, Bureau Chief; Budd A.
Hetrick, Jr., Deputy Bureau Chief; Roger
Hales, Administrative Attorney; John Kersey,
Chief Investigator; Roger Gables, Deputy
Attorney General; Dee Ann Randall,
Administrative Secretary
Minutes
Moved by Paul Morgan, seconded by Doyle Pugmire
and carried that the minutes of the February 11, 2002 board meeting be approved.
Rayola Jacobsen
Ms. Jacobsen informed the Board that their
proposed rules were approved by concurrent resolution and are effective March
13, 2002. HB427 passed and will be
effective July 1, 2002.
The Board was informed that the Bureau is looking
into changing the renewal date for licensees to either their birth date or date
of licensure. Discussion was held
regarding continuing education cycle. No
decision made.
George Andrade
George Andrade met with the Board to discuss his
education and experience and how this may meet the requirements for real estate
appraiser licensure. The Board will
notify Mr. Andrade in writing of their decision.
Executive Session
Moved by Doyle Pugmire, seconded by Paul Morgan
and carried the Board goes into executive session to discuss possible
litigation. The time being 9:45 a.m.
Moved by Paul Morgan, seconded by Gordean Briggs
and carried the Board comes out of executive session at 11:00 a.m.
It was the decision of the Board that Roger Hales
notify George Andrade informing him that the Board does not have the power or
authority to bypass the real estate appraiser laws or rules, and therefore he
must meet the requirements for licensure as set forth in the laws and rules and
advising him of the requirements he has met.
Complaint Report
Moved by Gordean Briggs, seconded by Paul Morgan
that the Board authorize Mr. Gables to proceed with a consent order on case
REA-P3-02A-99-024 whereby the respondent’s license is suspended for a minimum
of 30 days and Respondent is ordered to pay $1,000 fine and $250 in attorney
fees and investigative costs, take either a property inspection course or a
residential cost approach course in addition to continuing education required to
maintain licensure, and is place on probation for one year.
Doyle Pugmire recused himself from this case.
Moved by Doyle Pugmire, seconded by Paul Morgan
and carried the Board authorizes Mr. Gable to proceed with a consent order on
case number REA-L1A-01-00-020 to suspend the license for a minimum of 30 days
and pay $1,000 fine and $250 in attorney fees and investigative costs, take a
USPAP course in addition to continuing education required to maintain licensure,
and be placed on probation for one year.
Moved by Doyle Pugmire, seconded by Paul Morgan
and carried that the Board authorizes Mr. Gables to enter into a consent order
on case numbers REA-L3-03-00-027 and REA-L3-03-01-018 to suspend the license for
a minimum of 30 days, suspension stayed, running concurrently with a one year
probation, pay $1,500 fine and $250 attorney fees, take a USPAP course in
addition to continuing education required to maintain licensure.
REA-S1-02A-01-012; REA-S2C-02A-99-028;
REA-S2C-02A-99-029; REA-S1-02A-01-013; REA-S1-02A-01-014; REA-S1-02A-01-015;
REA-S1-02A-01-016 and REA-S1-02A-01-017 – Moved by Gordean Briggs, seconded by
Paul Morgan and carried, that the Board authorizes Mr. Gables to enter into a
consent order: 1) the non-supervisory license (licensed residential) is
suspended for a minimum of 120 days with 60 days suspended and pay $2,000 fine
and $500 in attorney fees and investigative costs; 2) the supervisory licenses
(the certified residential appraisers) are suspended for a minimum of 120 days
with 30 days suspended and each is ordered to pay $2,000 fine and $500 in
attorney fees and investigative costs; 3) each respondent is ordered to take a
15 hour USPAP course in addition to continuing education required to maintain
licensure, and 4) each Respondent is placed on probation for one year. Doyle
Pugmire recuses himself of this case.
REA-P3-01-99-020 – Moved by Doyle Pugmire,
seconded by Paul Morgan and carried that the Board authorize Mr. Gables to enter
into a consent order whereby the respondent receives a stipulated reprimand and
pay $500 in fines and $250 attorney fees and investigative costs.
REA-L3-02A-98-029 & REA-L1A-02A-00-012 –
Moved by Doyle Pugmire, seconded by Paul Morgan and carried that the Board
authorizes Mr. Gables to enter into a consent order to suspend the license for a
minimum of one year with ten months stayed, pay $4,000 fine $2,000 stayed and
$250 attorney fees and investigative costs, take a 15 hour USPAP course in
addition to continuing education required to maintain licensure and probation
for one year.
REA-L3-01-00-003 & REA-P3-01-01-006 – Moved
by Doyle Pugmire, seconded by Paul Morgan and carried that the Board authorizes
Mr. Gables to enter into a consent order whereby respondent receives a
stipulated reprimand, pay $500 to $1000 fine and $750 attorney fees and
investigative costs and one year probation.
Moved by Stan Moe, seconded by Gordean Briggs and
carried that the Board recommends remanding the case of William Votaw
back to the hearing officer for a complete transcription of the hearing.
Mr. Kersey reported that for fiscal year 2002
twenty-one (21) complaints have been received.
Of those eighteen (18) remain open and under investigation.
Twenty-one (21) complaints have been received for
the year 2001. Of those, four (4)
are under investigation the remaining are under legal review.
Thirty (30) complaints were received for the year
2000. Of those six (6) remain under
investigation. Eleven (11) are
under legal review.
Forty-seven (47) complaints were received in
1999. Three (3) are being scheduled
for an administrative hearing. Nineteen
(19) are under legal review.
Thirty-seven (37) complaints were reviewed in
1998. Seven (7) are being scheduled
for administrative hearing. Two (2)
are under legal review.
Thirty-two (32) complaints were received in 1997.
Three (3) are being scheduled for an administrative hearing.
Continuing Education
American Society Of Farm Managers And Rural Appraisers –Washington Chapter
“Spring Meeting 2002: Agricultural Property Development And Private Property Rights”
Requesting 10 hrs. CE - Approved for 4 hours CE
Idaho State Tax Commission
Summer Appraisal School
“Appraisal Review”: approved for 14 hours CE
“Commercial Appraisal; Bank Valuation,
Convenience Store, Restaurant” - Approved for 7 hours CE per a day or 21 hours
CE for attending all three days.
National Business Institute
“Major Land Use Law In Idaho” - Approved for
7 hrs. CE.
Foundation Of Real Estate Appraiser (Frea) - Ross Acheson
“F.H.A. Appraising “ Home Study Course - Approved for 25 hours CE.
“Modern Principals And Standards Of Real Estate
Appraising” Home Study Course Approved for 31 hours CE.
Montana Real Estate Institute – David Shoemaker
“Home Inspection” - Approved for 30 hours pre-licensure and CE.
“Advanced Writing Skills-Communicating The Appraisal”- Approved for 15 hour Pre-licensure and CE.
“Fundamentals Of Real Estate Appraisal I”- Aapproved for 30 hours pre-licensure and CE.
“Uniform Standards Of Professional Appraisal Practice 2002 National Course”- Approved for 15 hours pre-licensure and CE.
“Fundamentals Of Real Estate Appraisal II” -
Approved for CE - not approved for
Pre-Licensure. Sponsor needs to
submit more data to document basic course level.
The Chicopee Group – Carl Dutch
“Appraising Small Residential Income Properties” - Approved for 16 Hours Pre-Licensure or 15 Hours CE.
“The Fundamentals Of Real Estate Appraisal” - Approved For 32 Hours Pre-Licensure only, no CE hours.
“Applied Residential Appraisal Techniques I” - Approved for 16 Hours Pre-Licensure and CE.
“The Impact Of Real Estate Financing On Appraisal” - Approved for 8 hours CE
“The Cost Approach Revisited” - Approved for 8 Hours CE.
“The Income Approach Revisited” - Approved for 8 Hours CE.
“Professional & Technical Compliance With
USPAP IX” Requesting 4 Hours CE was not approved.
Lee & Grant Company – Stephen G. Patten
“Uniform Standards Of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP)” - Not approved for Pre-Licensure and CE.
“From The Appraiser To The Underwriter”-
Gordean Briggs to review course material for recommendation and approval.
Not approved at this time.
Mykut Real Estate School course “Appraisal
Methods” - Approved as an advanced course for certified residential and
certified general classifications through April, 2006.
AARO Conference
The AARO Conference is to be held in Seattle,
Washington April 27 – 30, 2002. If
Paul Morgan can make the arrangements, he will attend this meeting.
Distance Education
The Board adopts as policy the new distance
education criteria as adopted by the Appraiser Qualifications Board.
Applications Reviewed
The Board approved five (5) applications for
examination and deferred one (1) application.
Moved by Gordean Briggs, seconded by Stan Moe
that the certified residential application of Monty Egbert be approved as
minimally competent in meeting the requirements and he is eligible for the
certified residential examination. Paul Morgan recusing himself and Doyle
Pugmire voting no.
The Board authorized the issuance of the
following certificates/licenses to these individuals having met the educational
and experience requirements and passing an examination required by the Board.
Licensed Residential
Adam Thompson LRA-640
Kenneth Fields LRA-644
Gordon Bower LRA-616
Cindy Reed LRA-652
Thom Gough LRA-653
Shane Black LRA-670
Certified Residential
Paul Rundell CRA-634
Rodd Thornycroft CRA-664
Monty Egbert CRA-686
Certified General
Brent Smith CGA-630
Tyler Gardner CGA-642 Reciprocity with Washington
Douglas Rives CGA-658 Reciprocity with Oregon
Meeting adjourned at 3:00 p.m.
Approved 6/17/02
Return to Idaho Real Estate Appraiser Board Home Page
Return to Bureau of Occupational Licenses Home Page
Last Modified - April 11, 2006